Judge Lucy VanMeter Declares Candidacy for Kentucky Court of Appeals

Lexington, Kentucky – Fayette County Circuit Judge Lucy VanMeter has formally announced her candidacy for the Kentucky Court of Appeals in a press release on Wednesday. VanMeter aims to fill the seat recently vacated by Justice Pamela Goodwine, who was elected to the Kentucky Supreme Court in November.

In the interim, Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear appointed William Moynahan to occupy Goodwine’s position until the election scheduled for 2026. VanMeter’s candidacy brings a wealth of legal experience, bolstered by her years of service as a circuit judge.

Candidacy and Experience

VanMeter, a native of Bourbon County, has been a Fayette Circuit Judge since 2018, accruing over 20 years of experience in the state court system. Throughout her judicial career, she has presided over more than 40 trials, including notable high-profile cases such as the Sophia Rosing case, the John Tilley rape trial, and a murder trial linked to a botched robbery that resulted in the death of an 18-year-old. This extensive experience spans over 50 Kentucky counties, equipping VanMeter with the necessary skills to effectively serve on the Court of Appeals.

Professional Background

Before her appointment to the circuit court, VanMeter was an equity partner at the law firm Stoll Keenon Ogden PLLC in Lexington, where she worked for 17 years. Her legal acumen has been recognized by peers, with Bill Lear, the former managing partner at Stoll Keenon Ogden, praising her diligence and thoughtful approach as a judge. VanMeter’s educational credentials include graduating with honors from the University of Kentucky Rosenberg College of Law in 2001, along with a degree from DePauw University and her early education at Bourbon County High School.

Personal Life

In her personal life, VanMeter is married to Laurance VanMeter, who previously served as Chief Justice of the Kentucky Supreme Court after being elected in November 2022 and stepping down in 2024. This connection to a prominent judicial figure further illustrates her deep ties and commitment to the legal community in Kentucky.

Electoral Context

The 5th Court of Appeals District encompasses Fayette County, along with surrounding counties, including Franklin County. The primary election for the court is scheduled for May 19, 2026, while the general election will follow on November 3, 2026. Moynahan has expressed his intention to run for the seat in the upcoming election, setting up a competitive race.

Conclusion

Lucy VanMeter’s candidacy represents a significant development in Kentucky’s judicial landscape, offering voters a choice in experienced leadership for the Court of Appeals. As the election date approaches, her background and commitment to justice will likely play crucial roles in shaping public perception and support.